An Ash of War replaces the skill of a weapon or shield and, for many Ashes, also lets you infuse the weapon with an affinity such as Heavy, Keen or Fire. To apply one you need the Whetstone Knife: rest at a Site of Grace, choose the option to change the Ash of War, pick the weapon, then pick the Ash. Smithing Master Hewg at the Roundtable Hold can do the same job. Applying an Ash costs nothing and you can swap it back at any time.
What are Ashes of War and affinities?
Every armament has a weapon skill, the special move on the skill button. An Ash of War swaps that skill for another. Each Ash also has a "native" affinity, and when you apply it you can usually keep the weapon on Standard or choose the Ash's affinity (and, with the right Whetblade, a few others). An affinity changes the damage type, the stat scaling and sometimes the status build-up of the weapon. There are 13 affinities in total.
The base game has 91 Ashes of War, and Shadow of the Erdtree adds 25 more, which brings the total to 116. They drop from enemies and bosses, sit in chests and on corpses, and several merchants sell them.
How do you apply an Ash of War?
- Pick up the Whetstone Knife. It is in a chest in the underground cellar at Gatefront Ruins in Limgrave, together with Ash of War: Storm Stomp.
- Rest at any Site of Grace and choose the option to change the Ash of War, or talk to Smithing Master Hewg in the Roundtable Hold.
- Select the weapon or shield, then the Ash you want on it.
- If the Ash offers more than one affinity, choose one in the next menu. Standard keeps the weapon's own scaling.
A weapon carries one skill at a time. The old skill is not lost: removing an Ash returns it to your inventory and the weapon goes back to its default skill, and you can also move an Ash straight from one weapon to another. Each Ash only fits certain weapon types, which the item description lists, and unique weapons cannot be infused with an affinity at all.
Which affinities exist and what unlocks them?
Standard needs nothing. Every other affinity is unlocked by a Whetblade, and it only works on Ashes of the matching type. For example, the Sanctified Whetblade lets physical or golden Ashes take Sacred or Lightning, and the Glintstone Whetblade lets physical or magic Ashes take Magic or Cold.
| Whetblade | Unlocks | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| Iron Whetblade | Heavy, Keen, Quality | Stormveil Castle |
| Glintstone Whetblade | Magic, Cold | Academy of Raya Lucaria, in a side room west of the Debate Parlor Site of Grace, guarded by two Glintstone Sorcerers |
| Red-Hot Whetblade | Fire, Flame Art | Redmane Castle in Caelid, in a small building northwest of the Chamber Outside the Plaza Site of Grace |
| Sanctified Whetblade | Lightning, Sacred | Fortified Manor in Leyndell, Royal Capital |
| Black Whetblade | Poison, Blood, Occult | Night's Sacred Ground, lower Nokron, Eternal City |
One timing trap: the Red-Hot Whetblade is easy to miss. If you enter the Altus Plateau before picking it up, it becomes unobtainable until you have beaten Starscourge Radahn and finished Castellan Jerren's dialogue. Grab it while you are in Caelid.
What does each affinity do?
| Affinity | What it adds | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | The weapon's base attack power and scaling | Low stats, or when you want spell and grease buffs |
| Heavy | Strength scaling | Strength builds |
| Keen | Dexterity scaling | Dexterity builds |
| Quality | Balanced Strength and Dexterity scaling | Mixed Strength and Dexterity |
| Fire | Fire damage that scales with Strength | Strength builds that want fire damage |
| Flame Art | Fire damage that scales with Faith | Faith builds |
| Lightning | Lightning damage that scales with Dexterity | Dexterity builds |
| Sacred | Holy damage that scales with Faith | Faith builds |
| Magic | Magic damage that scales with Intelligence | Intelligence builds |
| Cold | Intelligence scaling plus Frostbite build-up | Intelligence builds that want status |
| Poison | Arcane scaling plus Poison build-up | Arcane builds |
| Blood | Arcane scaling plus Blood Loss build-up | Arcane builds |
| Occult | Arcane scaling that boosts the weapon's own status build-up | Weapons that already cause bleed, poison, madness or sleep |
Every affinity other than Standard trades something for its new scaling. Heavy, Keen and Quality lower the scaling of the other stats, the base attack power and the guard boost. The elemental and Occult affinities do the same and also lower guarded damage negation for other damage types.
Which affinities can be buffed?
This is the rule that catches people out. Only the four physical affinities (Standard, Heavy, Keen and Quality) accept spell buffs and greases. Magic, Cold, Fire, Flame Art, Lightning, Sacred, Poison, Blood and Occult do not. Skills that buff the weapon, such as Flaming Strike, work on any affinity, but some weapons (staves, Sacred Seals and bows) cannot be buffed at all.
The upgrade level matters as well. Cold, Poison and Blood lower the base scaling but raise the upgrade multiplier, so they gain more from smithing stones than their listed scaling suggests. An example from the wiki: a +25 Standard Zweihander scales D/C with Strength and Dexterity, while the same weapon on Cold scales C/C.
Which affinity should you pick?
- Strength is your main stat: Heavy, or Fire if the fire damage helps against your current area.
- Dexterity is your main stat: Keen, or Lightning for a purely elemental option.
- Both Strength and Dexterity are high: Quality.
- Intelligence build: Magic for damage, Cold if you also want frostbite.
- Faith build: Sacred or Flame Art.
- Arcane build: Blood for a hemorrhage weapon, Poison for poison, Occult on a weapon that already inflicts a status.
- Undecided or low stats: stay on Standard until your stats have settled. You lose nothing by re-infusing later.
Can you duplicate an Ash of War?
Yes. Smithing Master Hewg converts Lost Ashes of War into any Ash you already own, whether it is in your inventory or already on a weapon. The Lost Ashes of War is consumed in the process. That is how you put the same skill on two weapons. An Ash that a merchant sells can also be re-bought through the Twin Maiden Husks if the merchant dies, once you hand over the merchant's Bell Bearing.
Common mistakes
- Looking for an Ash in the wrong place: some weapons come with an Ash already equipped, and you can lift it off that weapon or duplicate it.
- Infusing a weapon to a stat you have not leveled. An affinity only helps if you have put points into the stat it scales with.
- Putting a grease or a buff spell on an elemental affinity. It will not work, so keep the weapon on a physical affinity if you rely on buffs.
- Missing the Red-Hot Whetblade before leaving for the Altus Plateau.
Which weapon should get which skill?
Match the skill to what the weapon is good at and what you can afford in FP. Many strong early picks are already the weapon's own skill, such as Unsheathe on the Uchigatana. See our beginner builds for weapons that fit each stat, and our parry guide if you want to put a parry skill on a shield.
FAQ
Do I need the Whetstone Knife?
Yes, to change Ashes at a Site of Grace. Without it you can still go to Smithing Master Hewg in the Roundtable Hold.
Does changing the Ash cost runes or items?
No. Only duplicating an Ash costs something, in the form of a Lost Ashes of War.
Why can't I pick an affinity I know I unlocked?
The Ash decides which affinities are offered. A Whetblade only widens the choice for Ashes of a matching type, so a Magic Ash will not offer Sacred.
Can I use my buff spells on a Fire or Magic weapon?
No. Only the physical affinities take spell buffs and greases. See the section on buffs above.
Smithing stones raise the weapon's attack power while the affinity changes how it scales, so the two work together. For stone locations, see the farming guide.