In Red Dead Redemption 2 the ending is decided by one choice in Chapter 6, not by your honor rating. Going back for the money leads to the bad ending and helping John escape leads to the good one. Honor then changes how the scenes play out and what you see in the final moments. Spoilers for the end of the story follow.
The Chapter 6 choice
During the escape from the camp, John tells Arthur that the money is still there. You can either go back to get it or help John get away. That is the only decision that changes the ending. The two paths play very differently:
Honor shapes how people treat you in every town.
- Go back for the money (bad ending): a duel with Micah in the cave ends in a draw. Dutch steps in, and Micah shoots Arthur.
- Help John (good ending): Arthur fights the Pinkertons on the cliffs and then Micah with his fists. Dutch stops Micah from finishing Arthur and lets him die in peace.
What honor changes
Honor does not decide which ending you get, but it changes the tone of many scenes. High honor and low honor give different reactions, and the differences are most visible near the end:
- Arthur's reaction to the news of his illness is serene at high honor and bitter at low honor.
- A deer appears to a high-honor Arthur, while a wolf or a black coyote appears to a low-honor one.
- Sadie and Charles speak to Arthur differently depending on how he has behaved.
- The tombstone changes, with flowers and an eagle at high honor, weathered stone and a coyote at low honor.
Together, the Chapter 6 choice and honor give four different outcomes. Both endings lead into the epilogue, where John moves from outlaw towards life as a farmer, closing with the last look at Dutch before 1911.
How to gain honor
- Greet people and pet dogs.
- Put money and items in the camp donation box.
- Help strangers and do camp chores.
- Pay your bounties, show mercy and release prisoners.
- Return fish you catch to the water.
How to lose honor
- Kill innocent people or lawmen.
- Rob shops, stagecoaches or trains.
- Steal horses.
- Harm animals such as pigs or dogs.
- Make harsh choices in missions.
At high honor, townspeople are friendlier and lawmen are more lenient. At low honor, lawmen are less forgiving and they respond faster. At the highest or lowest honor level you earn the trophy "Extreme Personality".
Bounties and the law
A crime with a witness puts a bounty on you, and the smallest bounty is 5 dollars. Bounties are tied to a region, and you can pay them at any post office, even in another area if the place where the crime happened is locked down. You can also surrender to lawmen when the bounty is not Dead or Alive, or serve a sentence. While you have a bounty, stagecoach and train fast travel is disabled.
- Wear a mask for non-violent crimes so witnesses cannot identify you.
- If a crime is seen, leave the red zone on the map quickly.
- Threaten a witness before they report you, if you want to avoid the bounty.
- Pay the bounty at a post office when you have the money.
Which ending should you choose?
If you want to see both, make a manual save before the choice in Chapter 6. The good ending is the more rewarding one in the story, and high honor makes it more emotional. Playing as a good outlaw also makes everyday play easier, since lawmen and merchants treat you better.
Quick tips
- Check your honor bar often, because one robbery can undo a lot of good deeds.
- Do not worry about honor too early. Your choices throughout the story still add up.
- For performance advice on PC, see the Red Dead Redemption 2 page.