The best weapon choices in Red Dead Redemption 2 are the Schofield revolver, the Lancaster Repeater, the Rolling Block or Carcano for sniping and the semi-auto shotgun, because each one can be bought or unlocked and fully upgraded. A fully upgraded standard gun can beat a unique weapon, so spend your money at the gunsmith instead of chasing rare finds.
Upgrades and upkeep
Ordinary guns can be customised and upgraded at a gunsmith, while unique weapons such as Granger's, Midnight's and Flaco's revolvers cannot. Unique guns have better base stats but you cannot improve them. Clean every weapon with Gun Oil, which the Trapper sells, every few in-game hours. A dirty gun loses accuracy and damage and reloads more slowly.
Revolvers
- Cattleman: the starting revolver. Strong and reliable.
- Schofield: available at gunsmiths or the Valentine drug-store back room, or via "Blessed Are the Meek" in Chapter 2. Several guides rate it the best revolver. Prices vary by source, so check the shop.
- Double-Action: available after "A Strange Kindness" in Chapter 2, or through the Sean homestead job. It fires faster than the Cattleman but is weaker per shot.
- Granger's Revolver: won in "The Noblest of Men, and a Woman" in Chapter 5.
Pistols
- Volcanic: unlocked after Chapter 2 (the Central Union Railroad camp). Eight rounds and strong.
- Semi-auto: unlocked after "The Joys of Civilization" in Chapter 4. The fastest fire rate of the pistols.
- Midnight's Pistol: a reward for defeating Billy Midnight.
Repeaters
The Lancaster Repeater is handed to you in "An American Pastoral Scene" in Chapter 2 and is the one most guides recommend upgrading. Other repeaters, such as the Litchfield and the Evans, become available later in the shops. A better repeater arrives in Chapter 6, so you do not need to hurry to buy them.
Rifles and snipers
- Springfield and Bolt-action: the Bolt-action is free after "Preaching Forgiveness as He Went" in Chapter 3 and is more accurate and quicker to reload.
- Rolling Block: your first sniper rifle, given at the Valentine gunsmith in "The Sheep and the Goats". It lasts well.
- Carcano: sold by the gunsmith in Blackwater, listed at about 1,100 dollars at normal honor and cheaper with high honor and fame. It has a better fire rate and reload, and it is the best choice for long range.
Shotguns
- Double-barrel: found above the chimney in "Paying a Social Call" in Chapter 2, or bought for about 95 dollars.
- Sawed-off: given in "Enter, Pursued by a Memory". A second copy costs about 85 dollars. It works only at close range.
- Semi-auto: unlocked after "A Fine Night of Debauchery" in Chapter 4, or found in the basement of Watson's Cabin northwest of Wallace Station.
Melee and throwing
The Trapper sells a tomahawk after "The First Shall Be Last" and throwing knives after "Paying a Social Call". The machete arrives in Chapter 5, and rare Hunter and Viking hatchets can be found in the world.
Which loadout to carry
Since you can only carry a limited number of weapons at once, think about the situations you meet most often: hunting, sniping, and close-range fights in towns or camps. Your horse carries the long guns, so you can swap them at any time.
- Early game: Cattleman, Lancaster Repeater and the Rolling Block for animals and long shots.
- Mid game: add the Schofield and a shotgun for close fights.
- Late game: swap in the Carcano and the semi-auto shotgun.
Quick tips
- Upgrade the guns you carry, not every gun you find.
- Rare shotguns and the rare Rolling Block from "Magicians for Sport" are re-skins of the standard guns.
- Check the RDR2 page if you want better performance.