To catch the legendary fish in Red Dead Redemption 2 you start the stranger mission "A Fisher of Fish" with Jeremy Gill, then catch each fish with the matching special lure and mail it from any post office. There are 13 fish to catch and mail for the first part of the mission. After you have mailed the 13th, Part II (Epilogue) is a story scene around a 14th fish, the Channel Catfish. A separate legendary, the Northern Pike, belongs to another stranger mission.
Starting the mission
Speak to Jeremy on the pier on the northeast shore of Flat Iron Lake in the Heartlands. He becomes available after the early chapters (sources disagree on whether that is Chapter 2 or 3). He gives you a handbill that lists the fish and which type of lure to use. Part II of the mission requires the Epilogue.
Lures and technique
- There are three special lure types: Special Lake Lure, Special River Lure and Special Swamp Lure. Buy them at a bait shop such as the one near Lagras or the one at the bayou.
- Any special lure works on any legendary fish, but the matching one bites faster, so use the right one when you can.
- Legendary fish ignore normal bait.
- Reel slowly, with occasional taps of the reel button, and be patient. Big fish must be carried on your horse.
The 13 fish for the first part
| Fish | Where | Lure |
|---|---|---|
| Steelhead Trout | River northeast of Brandywine Drop, north of Roanoke Ridge, near the islands | River |
| Perch | Elysian Pool, New Hanover | Lake |
| Longnose Gar | Swamp northwest of Lakay, south of Bluewater Marsh | Swamp |
| Muskie | River near Van Horn Trading Post | River |
| Bullhead Catfish | River island west of Sisika Penitentiary | River |
| Lake Sturgeon | Water west of Saint Denis near the southern tracks | River |
| Bluegill | Between Rhodes and Braithwaite Manor | Lake |
| Chain Pickerel | Dakota River, northwest of Flatneck Station | River |
| Sockeye Salmon | South shore of Lake Isabella | Lake |
| Smallmouth Bass | East shore of Owanjila Lake, west of Strawberry | Lake |
| Rock Bass | Aurora Basin, west of Tall Trees | Lake |
| Redfin Pickerel | Stillwater Creek, west part, east of MacFarlane's Ranch | Lake |
| Largemouth Bass | San Luis River bend southeast of Lake Don Julio, New Austin | River |
The last three on the list (Rock Bass, Redfin Pickerel and Largemouth Bass) cannot be fished until the Epilogue, so don't expect to finish the set before the late game.
The 14th fish
After you mail the 13th fish, wait a few in-game days and read Jeremy's invitation letter. It sends you to the San Luis River in New Austin, south of Benedict Point, where Jeremy hunts the Channel Catfish; you cannot catch that one yourself. Northern Pike is a separate legendary catch tied to the stranger mission "The Veteran" in the O'Creagh's Run area.
Step by step
- Meet Jeremy at Flat Iron Lake and take the handbill.
- Buy a few special lures of each type, so you do not have to return to the shop.
- Pick a fish from the list above, ride to its water, and cast with the matching lure.
- Reel in slowly. Put the fish on your horse and ride to a post office.
- Mail the fish and repeat until all 13 are sent, then wait for the final letter.
Rewards
Jeremy rewards your progress along the way, with a lake lure after the first fish, some cash and food after ten, and the best lure in the game, the Special Spinner, at the end of Part II. Treat the exact amounts as approximate, as sources differ on them. The Special Spinner works on any fish.
Quick tips
- Do the fish in a geographic order rather than list order to save travel time.
- Take the three Epilogue fish last, since they are not reachable earlier.
- For frame rate advice, see the RDR2 page.